A Blog About Making Culture
Inequality
April 5, 2005
Maciej is (1) a friend (2) very funny and (3) in agreement with my beliefs, so I couldn't resist linking to Dabblers and Blowhards, his new essay.
But the key issue that appealed to me about his piece is that the fundamental problem with many people who really get our goat on the Internet is that they do it by talking about things that we care about, that we know a lot about or that we are knowledgeable about, without sharing any of these traits.
It may be helpful to create a table of equivalence, in the same way that a chef might substitute honey for sugar in a recipe if they've run out. Only, in this case, it's bits of knowledge which can't be substituted for one another. (These are all transitive.)
- Being a geek growing up != Sociology or anthropology degree
- Coming up with an idea != Inventing something
- Knows a programming language != Understands politics
- Loud != Persuasive
- Gets other people to stop talking != Persuasive
- Coding Skill != Talent in Management, Business Development, Marketing, or the practice of Law
- Writes a lot != Writes well
- Funny != Correct
- Similar to me != Correct
- Well known != Respected
- Rude != Honest
- Polite != Honest
- Fast != Smart
I'm sure there's lots more, but these are the first ones that popped to mind.
Previously: The Man Who Saved The World
Next: Equivalence
Preoccupations
Food, creativity and play: The meal at QI last night (previous posting) was excellent. The menu was composed by Paul as a tribute to the part that food played in Lytton Strachey's life: he enjoyed his food and had a prodigious appetite. Frisée, bacon read more »Andre Torrez
Interactive != Moving
rebecca blood 
certain != right
interest != experience
enthusiastic != expert
academic, journalist, observer != practitioner
chewybrain
Opinionated != Informed Salad dressing != Gravy
josephgrossberg
Educated != Smart Popular != Talented Wealthy != Deserving High-ranking != Competent
NickFitz
Has Over 90% Market Share != Is De Facto Standard
memer
“Anybody going slower than you is an idiot, and anyone going faster than you is a maniac.” ~ George Carlin
It’s just Paul’s opinion. I’m sure, if he wanted to, Graham could find a number of “experts” who would agree with him. And all these != equivalences apply to everybody, Mr. Funny and Well-known ;-)
Dan S.
memer: A != B does not mean mutually exclusive. A person or expression can be both funny and correct, funny != correct only means to say one does not imply the other. I don’t think there’s a sense in which these statements only apply to some people, they’re either true or they’re not.
memer
Hanh? Did you mean me, Dan? What does that have to do with what I said?
Post a comment