How (Blogging) Awards Work

Every few days, I get sent a link to someone who's running a blogging awards contest. Sometimes it's for all blogs, and other times it's focused on a specific community. Interestingly, the category titles remain pretty much the same whether it's for a particular community or web-wide, with breakouts by geography or ethnicity or identity group.

The thing to understand about these awards, whether it's the Bloggies or the Weblog Awards or the PR bloggers' awards or the HR bloggers' awards, is that they serve a few roles. First, of course, is to recognize achievements within a community. But just as important is to define a community as existing. By categorizing community members, acknowledging the influencers/achievers, and classifying a second tier of runners-up, an award competition can help form a more formally-defined community, albeit at the expense of creating an explicit hierarchy.

The last reason that blogging awards are so popular isn't usually mentioned, but a powerful incentive for hosting and running an awards competition is to help make the host a center of power in the community. By creating the forum, inciting the inevitable drama, setting the rules, and (likely) helping to entrench one's friends and supporters as powers within the new community hierarchy, those who create awards are likely to reap significant benefits from doing so.

None of this is unique to weblogs, of course. People have been granting awards for as long as they've been getting inspiration from others. But what's been interesting for me to watch over the last 6+ years in the blogosphere is how each separate community (and sub-community) now spends some of its time dividing itself up and handing out ribbons.

It's interesting, given that quizzes and memes are among the most popular content in the blogosphere, that creating awards contests isn't something that's generally done by all bloggers. I'd expect at some point in the future there will be more simple apps for creating your own personal award show, given all the incentives that exist for doing so. I'd also expect that if such things already exist, someone will let me know.

10 Comments

If you are looking for something unique. I'm hosting a blog awards with no best blog, best new blogs and all that crap. It's all best niche blog.

http://www.kbcafe.com/iBLOGthere4iM/?guid=20051215070634

See also this month's Harper's magazine for an interesting reading about the overall explosion of awards in every field.

There are blogging awards??

It's funny how many people say they hate the awards, but no one really wants to be left out.

The biggest disincentive for me with these "awards" programmes is having to stick a tacky logo onto your site for consideration. The Irish version--the Golden Spiders--has totally debased the concept of "well-done" in the internet industry.

Anil, you make a good point that I hadn't thought of before - that the creation and bestowal of blogging awards tends to legitimize blogging in the public eye. I've blogged about the morality of blog awards, but I didn't consider that particular effect that they can have.

Overall, I think blogging awards are good because they encourage people to blog better - but of course there are drawbacks like biased award programs, traffic-hungry awards sites, and mudslinging campaigns to get the most votes.

Anil, you make a good point that I hadn't thought of before - that the creation and bestowal of blogging awards tends to legitimize blogging in the public eye. I've blogged about the morality of blog awards, but I didn't consider that particular effect that they can have.

Overall, I think blogging awards are good because they encourage people to blog better - but of course there are drawbacks like biased award programs, traffic-hungry awards sites, and mudslinging campaigns to get the most votes.

I agree with this post. I also offered an alternative suggestion in the comments at Easton's blog.

Yes, there should be more sites similar to that of Weblog Wannabe's Award-o-matic. LOL.

When I search in Google I saw this site --> http://www.dashawards.com - The One and Only Award Site for the Domain Name with DASH!

It's very funny that someone create an award site for websites with dash only...I think he is very creative and unique...but overall he's funny!

I think it's also a good niche for him...he is the first for it.

Leave a comment

Explore This Site

Recent Comments

Recent Entries

  • Burying The Lede

    I think one of the biggest reasons many great writers go into journalism is for the chance to sneak little wisecracks in, with the hope...

  • I Am Telling You This

    As always, I am trying to be everywhere at once. Here's where I've succeeded: * Dan Costa at PC Magazine offers a look at the...

  • Alan Leeds and Who Writes the Web

    One of the most frequent questions I get when I talk to people who are unfamiliar with social media on the web is, "Who writes...

  • Ubiquity

    Right now I am here, but soon I may be somewhere near you! Let's see where I've been lately, and where I'm going to be:...

  • Seven is Angry, Sadly

    Each year, I try to write a memorial post on the anniversary, to remind myself, and as a record of where I am compared to...

What I'm Up To

Thursday

  • Anil tweeted, "Getting inordinately excited about seeing Maxwell tonight."
  • Anil tweeted, "Leaks are bewing fixed. Scaffolding is being removed. Skilled laborers are at work."
  • Anil tweeted, "Okay, pretty soon I'm gonna go down to Wall Street and call "Bowser Revolution!" and just randomly reassign all the coins. Who's with me?"
  • Anil tweeted, "Having again braved the inscrutable and superstitious ways of the transhudsonic peoples, I am safely home at last in New York Civilization."

Wednesday

Tuesday

  • Anil tweeted, "This whole financial bailout kind of feels like the opposite of being in the audience during an Oprah's Favorite Things episode."
  • Anil tweeted, "Am I the only one who experiences Pacific Time as a sense of continuously being three hours behind and never catching up?"
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
  Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan
  Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb
  Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar
  Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr
  May May May May May May May May May
  Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun
Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul
Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug
Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep
Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct
Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov  
Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec