Quantcast Where's the logo critique? - Anil Dash

Where's the logo critique?

Hmm, MSNBC gets a brand-new logo, presumably as part of the new "spectrum" campaign they're doing, and yet Brand New has no review of it! The shame!

It looks like SS+K (whose site is shamefully under construction in a very 1998 way), has been leading the effort to brand MSNBC as a "Fuller Spectrum of News". Though it's alluding to the peacock logo MSNBC inherited from its NBC parentage, there's clearly an allusion to having a broader focus of coverage than Fox News, too.

The lame part is the showcase at the "Spectrum" site, though. There's a thing called "Spectrum TV", which I thought might be an interesting visualization of their new initiative, but is basically just a trailer showing off the colors of the rainbow. There's a screensaver, but I'm not really going to download an executable onto my system so that MSNBC can advertise itself. And there's a game "NewsBreaker", which I think is just a Breakout clone with headlines. That's about two decades too late, and you can't even play it yet anyway. They've got a long way to catch up to the addictiveness of Desktop Tower Defense.

And then of course the whole thing is wrapped up in a Flash movie so I can't link to any of these elements anyway. It'd all be forgiveable if the lettering in the new logo wasn't so wonky-looking. Hello, design blogs, help me out here!

Related Entries

5 Comments

Desktop Tower Defense is great.

Hey Anil,

The marketing campaign is intended to signal the beginning of an entire relaunch, the [very meager] first step of which is the logo redesign. You will see the site change dramatically (very dramatically) in coming several months. I think by the end of summer you’ll see us doing stuff that you can’t find elsewhere.

I agree: right now, some of the marketing material looks weird without the context of a future you can’t see. It was one of those things where the timing of various pieces didn’t match perfectly, but I hope the end effect will be noticed.

Also, I’d be curious what you think of other parts of the marketing campaign, which includes tv and print. For instance, check the ad in the most recent New Yorker, opposite Talk of the Town. I think there’s something kinda edgy about it, but, as with all marketing campaigns, not everyone likes it.

-Rex (Exec. Producer at MSNBC.com and that Fimoculous guy)

Hey Rex, thanks for the info. This highlights why I hate to rant about anything on my blog anymore — there’s always someone involved with the effort who has a reasonable response! :)

I do know, all too well, how hard it can be to have all the components of an initiative all launch at the same time, and I am definitely curious about the “spectrum of news” idea, so I’ll be keeping my mind (and eyes) open. Thanks for the info.

Heh, dude, I know that exact feeling all too well.

I would hate to disappoint my fellow bloggers, so here’s the logo critique.

Leave a comment

Explore This Site

Recent Comments

  • Busby Seo Challenge’s guy recommends the excel that runs on vista. I think it’s the 2007...

  • Anil, you are right on every point! I’ll add that the motivation appears to be greed; the bott...

  • Hi there Anil. My two teenage daughters rushed out to the bookstore the other night and came back wi...

  • If I’m ever arrested on COPS I’ll be sure to shout your name, Ronnie Dobbs-style. Maybe ...

    Victor Agreda Jr
    Me and Your Bicycle
  • Thanks very much Anil! Also, you may want to know I also credit you for turning me on to ABBA. Or bl...

Recent Entries

  • Find me on Beet.TV

    Andy Plesser of Beet.TV stopped by our offices at Six Apart a few weeks ago, and I had the chance to talk to him for...

  • More Cranky Geeks!

    I'm on Cranky Geeks again tomorrow. Usually I cringe a little seeing myself on these things, but I think this time around we all acquitted...

  • Goodbye, Godfather

    To those of us who grew up after his artistic heyday, James Brown is some combination of legend, influence, icon, and inevitably, caricature. So on...

  • The Festival of Pork

    Over on Serious Eats, 30 Days of Pork. Amanda's project makes so much sense to me. Just one of the highlights of an all-pork day...

  • How to kill a personality

    About a month ago, Fortune's Jeffrey O'Brien interviewed Seagate CEO Bill Watkins, and pulled the conversation's most memorable quote for the headline: "Let's face it,...

What I'm Up To

Today

  • Anil tweeted, "@jakedobkin Your "Dramatic Chipmunk" t-shirt is just an artifact of an unfunny, tired meme. Whereas a shirt with me on it... oh, wait."

Monday

  • Anil tweeted, "Holy fuck, people, just because a song mentions "America" and is played in a public venue doesn't mean we have to doff our hats and stand."

Sunday

  • Anil tweeted, "I have this horrible vision of the future where the family from these "don't throw away the rollover minutes" commercials gets a sitcom."

Saturday

  • Anil tweeted, "Everybody tweet me links to headlines saying "Biden: His Time" or similar lunacy!"
  • Anil tweeted, "Saw a bunch of paparazzi milling about on the sidewalk, presumably waiting for someone. Looks like chickens in the yard waiting for feed."

Friday

Thursday

1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
  Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan Jan
  Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb Feb
  Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar Mar
  Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr Apr
  May May May May May May May May May
  Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun Jun
Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul Jul
Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug Aug
Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep Sep  
Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct Oct  
Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov Nov  
Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec Dec  
Close